Investing in Israel: Ori Eyal, Emerging Value Capital Management
Ori Eyal
Founder and Managing Partner
Emerging Value Capital Management
Ori Eyal is the Founder and Managing Partner of Emerging Value Capital Management (EVCM) with over 12 years of experience in global value investing. EVCM manages a global, long-short, value hedge fund which invests based on Mr. Eyal’s proven global value investing framework.
Born in Israel and raised both in Israel and the U.S., Ori has a strong understanding of how to invest in both developed and emerging markets. Previously, Ori performed global investment analysis at Deutsche Bank Asset Management, Deephaven Capital Management and at Aquamarine Fund.
Ori won first place in the LCG investment challenge (National Value Investing Competition) and third place in the VCIC (National Venture Capital Investing Competition). He presented at several prestigious conferences including the Value Investing Congress (California), The Value Investing Seminar (Italy), the Best Ideas Conference (Online), and ValueX (Zurich).
Ori is a founding member of Entrepreneur Organization’s (EO) Israel branch. EO just published a new book about Israeli Entrepreneurship titled: “Israeli Entrepreneurs Handbook”. He will be mailing a free copy of the book to the first 50 readers that send in their mailing address to: ori@emergingvaluefund.com or click on link below:
Request a Free Copy of the Israeli Entrepreneurs Handbook
Professional investors, funds and allocators contact
Khai@hvst.com
to be part of our Harvest Interview Series
O
Harvest Interview Series: Value Investing in Israel
Ori Eyal
Founder and Managing Partner
Emerging Value Capital Management
{ INTERVIEW BY KHAI NGUYEN }
Ori Eyal is the Founder and Managing Partner of
Emerging Value Capital Management (EVCM) with over 14
years of experience in global value investing. EVCM
manages global, long-short, value hedge funds which
invest based on Mr. Eyal’s global investing framework.
Born in Israel and raised both in Israel and the US, Ori has
a strong understanding of how to invest in both developed
and emerging markets. Previously, Ori performed global
investment analysis at Deutsche Bank Asset Management,
Deephaven Capital Management and at Aquamarine Fund.
Ori won first place in the LCG investment challenge
(National Value Investing Competition) and third place in
the VCIC (National Venture Capital Investing
Competition). He presented at several prestigious
conferences including the Value Investing Congress
(California), The Value Investing Seminar (Italy), the Best
Ideas Conference (Online), and ValueX (Zurich).
Ori earned an MBA from the University of Chicago Booth
School of Business, an MSc in Computer Science from the
Open University of Israel and a BSc from the University of
Maryland. In addition to investing, economics and
emerging markets, his interests include logic games &
puzzles, artificial intelligence, strategy, science/physics/
astronomy, and the upcoming technological singularity.
Khai Nguyen: I'm here with Ori Eyal, Founder and Managing
Partner of Emerging Value Capital Management. Ori, welcome
and thank you for joining us.
Ori Eyal:
Khai, good to see you and thanks for having me.
KN: Your career, since 2001, has been focused specifically on
value investing. What about value investing makes it so
compelling to you?
OE:
While I started out as a Computer Scientist, I was always
interested in finance and economics. Around the year 2000, I
read “The Essays of Warren Buffett” and became a value
investing addict. Studying the writings of top value investors
including Warren Buffett, Charlie Munger, Joel Greenblatt, Seth
Klarman, David Einhorn and Bill Ackman has helped lay the
foundations for my investment framework. The basic tenets of
value investing make intuitive sense to me: buying something for
less than its worth, investing within your circle of competence,
demanding a large margin of safety, investing for the long term,
being contrarian, and the power of compounding over time.
Ever since, I have been on a journey to learn from the masters of
value investing and to develop my global value investing
framework. I earned my MBA at the University of Chicago -
Booth School of Business in 2006. I worked for Deutsche Bank
Asset Management as an analyst at one of their global investing
funds. I also interned for several hedge funds, including
Deephaven and for Guy Spier at Aquamarine.
KN: What were some of the investing lessons you took from Guy
Spier and incorporated into your investing process?
PRO
Professional investors, funds and allocators contact
Khai@hvst.com
to be part of our Harvest Interview Series
Around the year 2000, I read “The
Essays of Warren Buffett” and
became a value investing addict.
OE:
I was very fortunate to work for Guy Spier at Aquamarine
Fund while studying for my MBA at the University of Chicago.
Guy Spier is an extremely talented and thoughtful investor who
looks at the world as one global integrated market. Using his deep
insights into how the world operates and his latticework of
mental models, Guy has been able to successfully identify and
invest in some of the world’s greatest businesses.
At one point, Guy and I traveled to Israel together and we went to
visit and research about 15 undiscovered companies in Israel. In
some cases I think we were the first international investors that
had ever visited them. Watching Guy interact with the
management teams of these companies was a key learning event
for me. He has the ability to quickly develop rapport with
everyone in the room and get to the main business issues that
each company faces. By the time the meeting is over, Guy has a
better understanding of the business than the company
management team does. On top of that guy intuitively
understands the people running the company, their motives, and
their likely future behavior.
Working for Guy helped me develop my global value investing
framework. He taught me how to analyze great businesses and
how to approach and interact with company management teams.
He has been a great mentor, role model, and friend over the
years. When I launched EVCM Fund, Guy Spier was my biggest
supporter and my first investor.
KN: Who are some of the other investors that made an impact
on your investment philosophy and way of thinking?
OE:
Studying the investment history and writings of top value
investors including Warren Buffett, Charlie Munger, Joel
Greenblatt, Seth Klarman, David Einhorn and Bill Ackman has
helped lay the foundations for my investment framework.
Zeke Ashton of Centaur Capital has also been a great mentor,
teacher and friend. After I launched Emerging Value Capital,
Zeke was kind enough to invite me to his office and has helped
me further develop and refine my investment approach. Closely
studying the fantastic investing framework that Zeke has
developed as well as many of his specific investments, has been a
tremendous learning experience for me. I have also learned a lot
and continue to learn from my interactions with great value
investors including Monish Pabrai, Guy Spier, Whitney Tilson,
Glenn Tongue, Ken Shubin Stein and Rick Reiss.
KN: You founded, Emerging Value Capital Management, a
focused global value hedge fund in 2008. How was that
experience and what were the difficulties in launching your own
fund?
OE:
As the financial crisis of 2008 was unfolding, I saw that
tremendous bargains were being offered by the markets. Stock
were being sold indiscriminately as panic selling and forced
liquidations became common. While I did not know the exact
timing, it was clear to me that anyone with the courage and
conviction to invest capital into carefully selected stocks would end
up earning a fantastic return once the crisis had passed.
I therefore felt it was the right time to launch my global value fund
after years of developing and practicing my global value investing
framework. I resigned from Deutsche Bank and set up Emerging
Value Capital Management and its first fund (EVCM Fund) in
October 2008. EVCM is a long-biased global value fund. At EVCM,
I strive to integrate my global value investing framework with the
best practices and ideas from the value investors I have studied. In
hindsight I was a bit early as the markets kept declining until
March 2009. Still, my early investor’s courage and conviction was
rewarded with excellent returns.
As you can imagine, finding investors for a new hedge fund in 2008
and early 2009 was very difficult. Many investors were more
interested in buying canned goods and were worried about how to
protect themselves if the entire banking system collapsed.
Convincing them to invest in a new hedge fund was not an easy
task. At one point in late 2008, I attended an investing conference
where the overall mood was very gloomy. When I introduced
myself I said: “Hi, I’m Ori and I manage a small hedge fund”. To
which a few people jokingly replied: “All hedge funds are small
now”.
Despite the difficulties, I was able to find a handful of smart,
contrarian long term investors. They earned a great return
investing in EVCM Fund in 2008 and have continued investing
with me ever since. A big chunk of my life savings are invested in
EVCM fund so I “eat my own cooking”.
Having learned much from launching and managing EVCM Global
Fund in the last 6 years, I am now launching our second fund—The
Emerging Value Israel Fund (EVCM Israel Fund). While US
markets look expensive to me, I am finding cheap bargain stocks in
Israel and believe there is, once again, an opportunity to earn
outsized returns for investors willing to take a contrarian long term
approach.
KN: You grew up in Israel and received your Master’s degree in
Computer Science from the Open University of Israel. Being so
deeply rooted into the culture, what was it like growing up in
Israel and how did it shape your investment philosophy? In what
ways does this help or hurt you when investing in Israel?
Professional investors, funds and allocators contact
Khai@hvst.com
to be part of our Harvest Interview Series
Working for Guy Spier helped me develop
my global value investing framework. He
has been a great mentor, role model, and
friend over the years.
OE:
I was born in Israel but also lived for many years in the US.
Watching Israel grow economically and graduate from a
developing to a developed country has had a deep impact on my
thinking about economics and investment. Having an
international background, I became convinced that value
investing can and should be applied to global markets.
By comparing certain developed industries and companies in the
US to their less developed counterparts in Israel, I was able to
project the growth path of these Israeli companies. For example,
one of my first investments in 2001 was in an Israeli company
called Hilan Tech (HLAN). HLAN is the leading payroll processor
in Israel. Their main business is processing mid and large
company payrolls and issuing monthly paystubs to employees.
It’s the kind of repetitive, non-core and tedious process that most
companies choose to outsource. This makes HLAN’s customer
base very stable and the company a high quality cash-cow. By
comparing HLAN in its early stages to ADP and Paychex in the
US I was able to accurately predict the growth path and
profitability of HLAN. Over the years my investors have earned
an excellent return investing in HLAN and we still own it today.
Israel is well known for its technology focus and very
entrepreneurial workforce. Unofficially it has been called the
“start-up nation” since it has more start-ups per capita than any
other country in the world. Most of these start-ups are technology
oriented. To some extent this has resulted in less focus on
non-technology companies in Israel. Non-tech companies are
often overlooked by investors in Israel which creates an
opportunity for us. As a value investor, I love investing in stable,
boring companies that generate lots of cash. Israeli banks,
insurance companies, REITs, and old fashioned industrials may
not be as exciting as the hot new technology start-ups, but they
can often generate great returns for investors with much lower
risks. Taking advantage of this opportunity is one of the reasons I
decided to launch the Emerging Value Israel Fund.
KN: Why did you decide to launch a fund focused specifically on
investing in Israel and Israel related companies?
OE:
Earn a great return while supporting Israel. That is my
vision for setting up the Emerging Value Israel Fund. We are
launching the new Israel Value Fund in May 2015 because we
think there is an attractive opportunity to invest in cheap,
underfollowed Israeli value stocks.
After 14 years of global value investing, I am convinced that some
countries are simply better places to invest than others. It is of
critical importance that we invest in stable countries with regimes
that respect foreign investors and the rule of law. I also prefer to
invest in countries that have embraced capitalism and have free
markets.
In many respects, Israel is the perfect example of the kind of
country that global investors should seek to invest in. Israel is a
stable, capitalist, pro-business, pro-investors, free-market
democracy. Investors in Israel benefit from its strong property
rights, investor protections and respect for the rule of law. In
addition, serious corporate fraud is rare in Israel due to a zero
tolerance policy by regulators and courts. Having grown up in
Israel I can attest that most Israeli’s view foreign investors as
desirable, long term business partners that should be treated
fairly and respectfully. Partners, not patsies.
There are also multiple tail-winds that should drive the Israeli
economy forward over the next decade and beyond. First, Israel is
a world leader in technological innovation which is the driving
force of economic growth in the world. Second, an incredible
amount of natural gas has been discovered offshore near Israel
and it is coming online in the next few years. It will allow Israel to
become energy independent and will accelerate the entire Israeli
economy. Third, Israel has a pro-business government that is
constantly working to break up monopolies and increase
competition in the markets.
If you looked at a chart of the S&P 500 versus the Tel Aviv 100
(TA-100 Index) starting in 1997, you would see that despite
greater volatility and recent underperformance, the Israeli stock
market dramatically outperformed the S&P500. Accounting for
currency deprecations does not alter this picture by much. If we
are correct in our analysis, the Israeli stock market should
continue to outperform over the long term.
KN: What is your view on the Geopolitical situation in Israel?
OE:
While the newspaper headlines often look scary, I have a
somewhat contrarian view of Israel’s current macro and
geopolitical position. Many of the recent developments in the
region have actually improved Israel’s security situation. Egypt is
fighting terrorist attacks from both Hamas and Isis and as a
result has become a closer ally of Israel. The implosion of Syria
and the elimination of its chemical weapons stockpile has
removed a major military threat to Israel. Hezbollah, while still
trying to project strength, is mired in internal problems in
Lebanon and is losing its battle with Isis. Iran is, hopefully,
slowing down its nuclear weapons program as negotiations with
the US continue. So overall we see that many major threats to
Israel have been neutralized, or at least temporarily removed.
Professional investors, funds and allocators contact
Khai@hvst.com
to be part of our Harvest Interview Series
assessment of what the company might look like and be worth
under various future economic scenarios.
Every investment idea should pass four tests or filters before it
can be added to the portfolio. Is it within my circle of
competence? Is it a good business with permanent competitive
advantages? Is management capable, honest, and shareholder
friendly? And is it cheap?
For Circle of Competence we look at: Do I understand the
business and industry? Can we reasonably predict the company’s
future prospects and cash flows?
For Quality of Business we try to answer: What are the businesses
competitive advantages? What is its expected long term ROE and
ROA? Can the business grow profitably without requiring too
much capital? Is the balance sheet strong? What are the industry
dynamics? What is the long term outlook for the industry and the
business? Is the business recession resistant?
For Management we ask: Are they competent, shareholder
friendly, and good capital allocators? Have they created
shareholder value in the past? Can they articulate a clear plan for
increasing shareholder value?
For Price we determine: How cheap is the business? Is there a
large margin of safety? How much can we lose? Is it a favorable
risk/reward?
Finally, I use my extensive network and connections in Israel to
verify my investment thesis and to seek out different opinions
about the company and its management team.
KN: What are two interesting companies you see in Israel right
now from a value investing perspective?
OE:
We are finding a lot of interesting value companies in Israel
so it’s difficult to pick just two, but I will discuss a few.
The first is Israel Discount Bank. Israel Discount Bank (IDB) is
the third largest bank in Israel. Incorporated in 1938, it has since
grown its equity to over 12 billion ILS and its branch network to
At EVCM, I strive to integrate my global value
investing framework with the best practices and
ideas from the value investors I have studied.
In addition, the sharp drop in the price of oil is a huge benefit to
Israel. It reduces the funds available to the countries and terrorist
organizations that wish to harm Israel. It is also helping
transform the world economy where the driving force is now
technological innovation instead of access to oil and scarce
resources. Israel, a world leader in technical innovation, is well
positioned to prosper in this new world economy. In contrast,
many of the countries and terrorist organizations that wish to
harm Israel are completely dependent on selling oil for high
prices and may even collapse if oil prices stay low. Given all of the
above, I would argue that Israel is actually in one of the best
security and geopolitical positions it has ever been in its history.
When investors realize this, Israeli stocks should go up.
KN: Can you explain your fund strategy and investment process
for investing in Israel?
OE:
The new Israel Value Fund will invest mostly in Israeli and
Israel related companies. There are about 600 publicly traded
companies listed on the Tel-Aviv stock exchange in Israel. There
are another 120 Israeli companies listed on foreign exchanges. Of
all these, about half are investable in terms of minimum
market-cap and trading liquidity. So my task is to thoroughly
research and analyze the investable universe of about 360 Israeli
stocks and to own the most attractive 10 to 20 stocks at any given
time.
I initially search for potential ideas by talking to other investors
and fund managers, reading Israeli newspapers, attending
conferences, reviewing my stock watch lists, and screening for
cheap stocks. Once I find an investment idea that looks
potentially interesting I do independent in depth research and
analysis. First, I read and analyze all available financial filings of
both the company and its main competitors. Second, I often try to
speak directly with management to assess their competence,
future plans, capital allocation skills, and respect for
shareholders. Third, I study the industry and the where the
company is heading. I then combine all of these into an
Tel-Aviv 100 Index (blue) vs. S&P500 (red) – 1997 to 2014
Professional investors, funds and allocators contact
Khai@hvst.com
to be part of our Harvest Interview Series
over 230 locations, inclusive of the 100% owned mercantile bank
locations. Its major business lines include retail banking,
corporate banking, financial management, capital markets and
private banking. IDB also has key overseas operations in the US,
Switzerland, and the UK.
Operationally, IDB is the least efficient major bank in Israel. Its
employees belong to a fairly militant union so they make cost
cutting and operational improvements an always difficult
undertaking. As a result IDB suffers from a bloated cost structure
and earns sub-par returns on equity, with sustainable ROE
currently around 7%. The market is well aware of these issues and
therefore values IDB at a low price to book ratio of only 0.5.
IDB recently got a new CEO, Ms. Lilach Topilsky. Previously,
Topilsky led the operational turnaround in Bank Hapoalim,
Israel’s largest and most efficient bank. We think Topilsky will, in
time, be able to cut IDB’s cost structure and improve its
sustainable ROE to around 9%, which would warrant a 0.9 price
to book multiple. That’s a potential 80% upside from current
prices.
IDB also has hidden assets which provide strong valuation
support. We value IDB New-York at about 2.8 billion ILS, which
is less than book value. We value 72% owned Visa Cal at 1 billion
ILS or 10X normalized net income. Excluding these two assets,
we find “Core-IDB” trading for just one third of book value. A
price that is too cheap and should increase as assets are sold
and/or ROE improves.
Another compelling value idea is Golf & Co (“Golf”). It is a
leading group of retail chain stores located in Israel, all under the
umbrella brand “Golf”. The stores fall into two main retail
categories: fashion clothing and home accessories. Golf has 281
stores today across all its sub-brands. Sub-brands include Golf
Kids & Baby (kids clothing), Intima (lady undergarments), Polgat
(men’s suits), Max Moretti (lady shoes, purses and accessories),
Blue Bird (surf wear), Golf & Co (home accessories), and others.
As the largest retail chain in Israel, Golf enjoys multiple
competitive advantages including a strong and well recognized
brand, excellent mall based locations and economies of scale in
distribution, operations, advertising and purchasing. The Golf
brand is generally associated with good value for money, but is
not necessarily the most fashionable or cutting edge.
Golf is a slow-growth, conservatively managed cash generating
business. It has recently started implementing its strategic plan
to increase shareholder value. The company will refocus and
revamp its core brands and leverage its economies of scale to
make bolt on acquisitions. In addition to acquisitions, the
company plans to open around 40 new stores in the next three
years which implies about 4% organic growth per year in the
store count.
Golf experienced a weak 2014 due to the war in the Gaza Strip.
People don’t usually go shopping when missiles are flying. 2015
should be back to normal and Golf could earn operating profits of
65 million ILS. The company also has a strong balance sheet with
plenty of cash and no debt.
At Golf’s current stock price we are paying just 5.5X EV / EBIT.
While this price is already cheap, we note that one of their
sub-brands, Blue Bird, is currently losing about 10 million ILS a
year. We expect that over the next few years Golf will either
return this store chain to profitability or else shut it down.
Excluding Blue Bird, Golf trades for under 5X EV / EBIT, an
unreasonably cheap price. The company currently pays a 10%
annual dividend yield although the dividend fluctuates from year
to year.
KN: How do investors generally get exposure to Israeli equities?
OE:
While many people and organizations around the world
want to invest in Israel in order to earn good returns and also to
support the Israeli economy, it’s actually not simple to do.
Because of strict US regulations, it’s difficult for US investors to
invest in the Israeli stock market. For example, most Israeli
banks and Israeli brokers will flat out refuse to open a new
account for a US investor simply due to regulatory restrictions.
This limitation has drastically reduced the number of Israeli
funds that are offered to US investors.
As a result, most foreign investors choose to invest mostly in
Israeli start-ups via the many venture capital (VC) firms in Israel.
We think VC and start-up investing are great, but want to
encourage investors to also consider other investment options
including value investing in more mature publicly traded Israeli
companies.
One way around this restriction is for US investors to open
accounts with large global investment banks such as JPMorgan or
UBS and have them purchase Israeli stocks for their account. The
problem with this approach, in addition to the large minimum
account size, is that most global investment banks don’t have a
physical trading desk in Israel. They often trade from London or
some other remote trading desk and therefore are removed from
the Israeli market and are unable to offer real-time market
insight or best execution.
At the Emerging Value Israel Fund we have found an excellent
structure that circumvents these issues. We custody with
While US markets look expensive to me, I am finding
cheap bargain stocks in Israel and believe there is,
once again, an opportunity to earn outsized returns
for investors willing to take a contrarian long term
approach.
Professional investors, funds and allocators contact
Khai@hvst.com
to be part of our Harvest Interview Series
JPMorgan which is widely regarded as safe and reputable. We
then use our local connections to execute most trades with local
trading desks in Israel. This gives our investors the best of both
worlds. Excellent local execution and market access combined
with the safety and peace of mind of having their capital under
custody at JPMorgan.
KN: Who would be the ideal investors for your New Israel Value
Fund?
to disrupt multiple industries. In short, we have entered the age
of technological innovation and disruption.
Israel is incredibly well positioned to succeed and even flourish in
this new age of technological innovation. It is a world leader in
start-ups, innovation, entrepreneurship, R&D, and advanced
technologies. Many of the world’s leading corporations know that
when they need top-notch, state of the art, ground breaking R&D,
Israel is the place to do it. It is not a coincidence that companies
like Google and Intel have extensive R&D in Israel.
Value investing in Israel is a smart way to participate in these
future trends and our new Israel Value Fund is positioned to
benefit from Israel’s future success.
KN: You mentioned something about a free book?
OE:
Yes. I am a founding member of Entrepreneur Organization’s
(EO) Israel branch. We just published a great new book about
Israeli Entrepreneurship and a select group of Israeli
Entrepreneurs. It’s titled: “Israeli Entrepreneurs Handbook”. I’ll
happily mail a free copy of the book to the first 50 readers that
send me their mailing address to:
ori@emergingvaluefund.com.
Disclosure:
This document does not constitute an offer to sell or the solicitation of an offer to purchase any
security or investment product. Any such offer or solicitation may only be made by means of
delivery of an approved confidential offering memorandum. Past results are no guarantee of future
results and no representation is made that an investor will or is likely to achieve results similar to
those shown. All investments involve risk including the loss of principal.
An investment in the Fund may be deemed speculative and is not intended as a complete
investment program. It is designed only for sophisticated persons who are able to bear the risk of
the substantial impairment or loss of their investment in the Fund. The Fund is designed for
investors who do not require regular current income and who can accept a certain degree of risk in
their investments. Prospective investors should carefully consider the risk factors specified in the
Offering Memorandum before making a decision to invest in the Fund.
Israel is well known for its technology focus and very
entrepreneurial workforce. Unofficially it has been
called the “start-up nation” since it has more startups
per capita than any other country in the world.
OE:
Earn a great return while supporting Israel. That is our
vision for setting up the Emerging Value Israel Fund. Interested
accredited investors and institutional investors should have a
value oriented mindset and should invest for the long term, with
a time horizon of at least a few years. Obviously we are looking
for investors that also support Israel, are impressed by how far
it’s advanced, and are excited about its future potential.
There is also an opportunity for one or more seed investors to
invest early and get equity in the management company. We
think this is a great deal for the right investor since their capital is
invested in a conservative value fund, yet the management
company equity potentially offers a big upside.
KN: You have a computer science background and have talked
in the past about how technology is shaping our future in
non-linear ways. How do you view the long term future for
Israel? Is it well positioned in this regard?
OE:
Technology is becoming a bigger and bigger part of our
economy and our lives. We tend to view technological progress as
moving at a linear pace but in reality many technologies progress
at an exponential pace. For example, we all know about Moore’s
law and how the costs of computing power, data storage, and
communication decline at an exponential pace. But did you also
know that the number of genes we can sequence per dollar cost,
the installed solar power generation capacity in the world, and
the resolution of brain imaging technologies are also all growing
at an exponent pace?
Because of this exponential technological progression, more and
more industries are getting disrupted. Land line phones, long
distance communication, brick and mortar retailing, travel
agents, and physical libraries are good examples of industries
that have already been disrupted by technology. And this is just
the beginning. New fracking technologies have disrupted oil and
gas exploration which is why we are seeing the large price
declines in these commodities. Uber is disrupting the world wide
taxi industry. Self-driving cars and 3D printing are poised to
Next
More from Harvest
The most important insight of the day
Get the Harvest Daily Digest newsletter.
