Matthias Knab
March 03, 2017
Founder of Opalesque

Could private equity be coming to a 401(k) account near you?

 

Read in Opalesque's new Private Equity Strategies how PE looks for a path Into the defined contribution market, and more:


- Regs Watch: Brief Updates on Changes in Regulation for Private Equity


- New guidelines on valuation, international taxes, and fund liabilities


- Movers & Shakers: Movers & Shakers


- Northern Trust Launches Blockchain Offering For Private Equity With IBM


- Data Snapshot: Private Equity Dry Powder Hits New Record


- Data Snapshot: Private Equity CTOs Add Outsourcing, Increased Security To Priority Lists


- Indigo Partners Low-Cost Airline Investments Take Off


- Quick Hits: Recent transactions, fund news, people moves, and events


Subscribe to this free Opalesque publication here: http://www.opalesque.com/subscribe-private-equity-strategies.html 

Copyright 2017 © Opalesque Ltd. All Rights Reserved.
1
1
Opalesque Private Equity Strategies
Issue 114 | February 28, 2017
Welcome to the latest issue of Private Equity Strategies. We are kicking off a new
year and a variety of concerns are battling for the tops of private equity’s priority
list. Our introductory piece looks at how Pantheon is trying to include private equity
investment opportunities in custom target date funds.
In our latest Opalesque Marketplace listing we highlight a new real estate opportu-
nity in Europe.
In our Movers and Shakers column, we caught up with Northern Trust about their
efforts to streamline private equity fund administration with blockchain technology.
Our data snapshots look at increasing levels of private equity dry powder and how
the role of the private equity CTO has evolved.
We also catch up with Indigo Partners a private equity firm that specializes in estab
-
lishing low cost airlines. Finally, our regular features - Regs Watch and Quick Hits keep
you up to date on new regulations and fund news.
I hope you enjoy the issue. If you have any story ideas reach out to mccann {at}
opalesque.com
Issue 114 | February 28, 2017
In This Issue
Private Equity Looks For A Path Into The
Defined Contribution Market ...... 3
Could private equity be coming to a 401(k)
account near you?
Regs Watch: Brief Updates on Changes in
Regulation for Private Equity.....................5
Links and brief updates on changes to the
regulatory landscape for private equity,
including: new guidelines on valuation,
international taxes, and fund liabilities.
Movers & Shakers: Movers & Shakers:
Northern Trust Launches
Blockchain Offering For Private Equity With
IBM.........................6
Private Equity gets into blockchain
Data Snapshot: Private Equity Dry Powder
Hits New Record..........7
Data Snapshot: Private Equity CTOs Add
Outsourcing, Increased Security To Priority
Lists........................8
Indigo Partners Low-Cost Airline
Investments Take Off..........................10
Quick Hits ............................................12
Recent transactions, fund news, people
moves, and events.
Private Equity
strategies
Copyright 2017 © Opalesque Ltd. All Rights Reserved.
opalesque.com
2
2
Opalesque Private Equity Strategies
Issue 114 | February 28, 2017
Copyright 2017 © Opalesque Ltd. All Rights Reserved.
opalesque.com
3
3
Opalesque Private Equity Strategies
Issue 114 | February 28, 2017
Bailey McCann
Private Equity Strategies
P
rivate equity as an industry has
come to rely on pension alloca-
tions as a significant, if not major
-
ity source of new allocations over the
years. That model has worked quite well
for a few decades, but now as retire
-
ment accounts shift from pension plans
to 401(k) and other defined contribution
vehicles, private equity isn’t part of the
mix. Private equity investments don’t
offer the daily liquidity that is often
required by these types of retirement
offerings. That’s sent the industry scram-
bling to find new ways of including
long-term investments in products that
are biased toward short-term liquidity.
Enter Pantheon. London-based Panthe
-
on, a veteran investor in private equity,
infrastructure, and real assets, has intro
-
duced a new product that would allow
custom target date funds to include
private equity in the asset allocation
mix. Notably, the product includes
performance-based pricing.
“We want to be able to offer the same
investment access and benefits to
the defined contribution market that
individuals in a defined benefit plan
receive,” explains Kevin Albert, Manag-
ing Director at Pantheon in an interview
with Private Equity Strategies. “Defined
benefit plans have been able to plan for
long-term funding by investing in asset
classes like private equity, but that secu-
rity is not available to the DC market.”
The U.S. retirement market consists
of both defined benefit (DB) and DC
plans, and more than 90 million U.S.
citizens are covered by DC plans, with
Private Equity Looks For A Path Into The
Defined
Contribution Market
DC assets in excess of $6.7
trillion. Historically, DB plans
have outperformed DC plans
for reasons that include a
shift toward alternative assets
and differing investment fee
structures. Based on the strong
returns the private equity asset
class has delivered in recent
years, Pantheon believes that
private equity strategies have
the potential to address the
performance delta between DB
and DC plans and merit consid-
eration as a viable investment
option by plan sponsors.
“We believe it is essential to
take action to close the perfor
-
mance gap between DB and
DC plans,” Albert says. “Research
shows that 52% of American
households are currently at
risk of not having enough to
maintain their living standards
during retirement.Retirees can
ill afford to suffer continued
underperformance in their DC
plans.”
The performance pricing
option applies only to that
portion of a portfolio actu-
ally invested in private equity
investments (e.g., not including
cash and liquid securities). A
performance-based fee is only
accrued when the performance
of the private assets in the
portfolio beats its benchmark,
which is the S&P 500.
Pantheon does not receive all
the performance fee it ac
-
crued immediately. When a
performance fee is accrued, it
is gradually paid to Pantheon
over at least eight calendar
quarters. This is so there can be
a reservoir available to reverse
performance fee accruals in
scenarios of underperfor
-
mance.
(Continued on the next page)
Copyright 2017 © Opalesque Ltd. All Rights Reserved.
opalesque.com
4
4
Opalesque Private Equity Strategies
Issue 114 | February 28, 2017
Because Pantheon’s strategy intends to accommodate periodic trading, and the fee accrued would be reflected in the
strategy NAV as of the relevant period, investors will not pay for performance they did not experience.
Pantheon is working with a number of General Partners, including KKR, to seek to manage the less predictable and
irregular investor capital inflows that can be expected in a DC plan, and to facilitate efficient deployment.
The types of private equity investments in the strategy will look roughly similar to others Pantheon already has. The
target-date fund team will be included as another client within the investment committee, which considers co-
investments, secondaries fund investments, infrastructure funds, buyouts funds, etc. “The product has the benefit of
offering diversification by manager not just by deal,” Albert contends.
Pantheon isn’t the only firm looking for new ways to include private equity in DC vehicles. Last week Blackstone
acquired Aon Hewitt’s record keeping business, which could signal the firm’s desire to infuse private equity in more
corners of the retirement market. Aon Hewitt is the fifth-largest record keeper of DC plans by assets, with $377 billion
under administration as of Sep. 30, 2015, according to Pensions & Investments data.
Prudential also offers a similar setup to DC plans for real asset investments that includes a mix of REITs and listed
infrastructure and real estate companies.
It’s still early days for the Pantheon product. The company has had several review sessions with private equity and
retirement plan consultants to ensure that it will fit the needs of custom target date funds and so far the reception has
been positive. “I think the key issue is, this is a new asset class for DC plan sponsors and everyone wants to make sure
they don’t get on the wrong side of risk and litigation concerns. We feel confident we’ve addressed those possibilities,”
Albert adds.
Copyright 2017 © Opalesque Ltd. All Rights Reserved.
opalesque.com
5
5
Opalesque Private Equity Strategies
Issue 114 | February 28, 2017
A
s journalists like me and lawyers
have written ad nauseum, new
and ever more regulations are
in the pipeline for private equity and
alternatives as a whole. Here we will
hit on some of the cases of note and
provide links to new guidance over the
past month.
India: Regulation Of Compensation
Agreements By SEBI
India is making changes to the way it treats
compensation agreements and that could
have a significant impact on private
equity firms in the region.
Read More.
All change for UK money launder
-
ing regulation? - Impact for the
private equity industry
Of particular interest to the private equity
industry will be the proposed new criminal
offence of failure to prevent the facilita-
tion of tax evasion, a strict liability offence
which will require consideration by way
of risk assessment and will need to be
addressed when formulating policies and
procedures.
Read More.
Private equity GPs fret over
fundrising and regulation
Regulation and fundraising stood out as
the most substantial challenges for private
equity fund managers (general partners, or
GPs) worldwide in 2016 and remain major
concerns in 2017, according to research by
private equity fund administrator Augentius.
Read more.
Trump Moves to Roll Back Obama-
Era Financial Regulations
President Trump has moved to chisel away
at the Obama administration’s legacy on
financial regulation, announcing steps to
revisit the rules enacted after the 2008 finan-
cial crisis and to back away from a measure
intended to protect consumers from bad
investment advice.
Read more.
Deregulation could add banks to
private equity sector
Fund managers at small, new or otherwise
aspiring private equity groups seem hopeful
a rising tide of deregulation in financial ser
-
vices could lift their ships as well.
Read more.
Credit easing, regulation put plans
on critical list
U.S. corporate defined benefit plans have
been closing and freezing benefit accruals
for decades, with a number of industry ex
-
perts pointing to the very regulations meant
to protect them as a top contributing factor.
Read more.
CSRC: China is to accelerate financial
reform
CHINA is trying to lure more foreign capital
into the mainland’s financial market and will
stick to the stance of reform and opening-
up, the country’s top securities regulator
said today during a press conference amid
recent regulatory signals for further financial
reforms.
Read more.
The Top Ten Regulatory and Litiga-
tion Risks for Private Funds in 2017
The top of every private fund adviser’s list for
2017 – and how to assess and manage the
associated risks.
Read more.
Regs Watch: Brief Updates on Changes in
Regulation for Private Equity
Sunken ship
President Trump’s latest private
equity hire Philip Bilden has
officially withdrawn his name from
consideration as Secretary of the Navy.
Bilden is a former managing director
with HarbourVest Partners and said
that he wouldn’t be able to disentangle
himself from his financial investments
in order to take the job.
Deal or No Deal
The proposed $31 billion merger between the London
Stock Exchange and Deutsche Boerse is likely dead. British
regulators said the deal wouldn’t pass anti-trust checks.
The merger would have combined stock exchanges in
the UK, Germany and Italy, plus many of Europe’s largest
clearinghouses.
The deal will also stop a €510 million sale of LCH Clearnet’s
French arm to Euronext. That deal was backed by LSE and
was contingent on the merger with Deutsche Beorse.
Copyright 2017 © Opalesque Ltd. All Rights Reserved.
opalesque.com
6
6
Opalesque Private Equity Strategies
Issue 114 | February 28, 2017
Movers & Shakers: Northern Trust Launches
Blockchain Offering For Private Equity With IBM
by
Bailey McCann
Private Equity Strategies
N
orthern Trust has launched the first commercial deployment of blockchain technology for private equity fund
administration. The firm is partnering with IBM for technology development, which works off of the Hyperledger
Fabric. Hyperledger is an open-source blockchain development platform that is focused on finding ways to use
distributed technology in financial services.
Northern Trust started working with $20 billion Swiss asset manager Unigestion, in 2016, to create the blockchain offer
-
ing for its private equity business. The blockchain platform has been designed to support compliance with current, local
regulations. Northern Trust will also make use of IBM’s high-security network for blockchain to ensure that private keys
and platform security are constantly maintained.
“One of the main challenges for private equity is certifying documents. Paper is being passed around for capital calls,
investments, and other transfers. Blockchain provides an immutable, certified record of which documents are current and
approved,” explains Peter Cherecwich, President of Corporate & Institutional Services, Northern Trust in an interview with
Private Equity Strategies.
According to Cherecwich, using blockchain will allow funds to have “one version of the truth” which will ultimately be able
to cut down the time from fund launch to capital deployment. Unlike traditional document management systems which
are often files of PDFs, distributed ledger technology ensures certification, permissioning, and version control so that
investors, external auditors, and others are always working from the most up-to-date materials without the possibility of
losing one or more PDFs. Funds that use the technology will also avoid being locked into a single vendor’s product line.
The Unigestion private equity fund that served as a trial balloon for this technology is domiciled in Guernsey. Cherecwich
says that Northern Trust went through an in-depth process including an external security audit by local regulators to get
the official sign off - a process it is prepared to replicate with other, popular fund domiciles.
“Guernsey has been at the forefront of innovation in the financial industry for many years. As a jurisdiction, we continu-
ally monitor new technologies, support businesses in developing groundbreaking new ideas and provide a supportive
environment where products can not only flourish but be first-to-market,” said Chief Minister of Guernsey, Gavin St Pier in
a statement on the launch.
Northern Trust will be making the platform available to other private equity firms and investors that have a relationship
with the firm. “We’d like to start building an ecosystem of GPs and LPs that are using the technology,” Cherecwich said. “We
have already had other firms reach out to us about getting involved.”
Copyright 2017 © Opalesque Ltd. All Rights Reserved.
opalesque.com
7
7
Opalesque Private Equity Strategies
Issue 114 | February 28, 2017
Data Snapshot: Private Equity Dry Powder
Hits New Record
With investors on the hunt for yield, PE remains a favored asset for institutional investors. Fundraising surged as limited partners
(LPs) continued to recycle distributions into new capital commitments. Returns also had another strong showing, continuing to
outperform public markets by a sizable gap over both short-term and long-term time horizons. Global buyout activity, on the other
hand, declined amid a challenging deal-making environment.
A new report from Bain & Company shows that it is becoming harder for private equity to deploy its billions and still find the kind
of returns it is used to. In 2016, buyout-backed exits around the world dropped 23 percent in value and 19 percent in count from
2015 and fell even further from the record levels of 2014. But, asset sales of $328 billion in disclosed value from 984 deals actually
constitutes an extremely strong run, helping the industry deliver its fourth-best year ever by value.
With nearly all of the pre-crisis deals exited, buyout firms are adjusting to a new normal with longer holding periods of about 5
years – up from the historical average of about 3.5-4 years. Bain expects this trend to continue in the medium term, as a result of
high purchase prices and limited sources of market beta, requiring general partners (GPs) to roll up their sleeves and do the time-
consuming work of creating value with their assets.
“Deals are undoubtedly hard to come by. On average, studies show that PE firms see less than 20 percent of deals relevant to them
in their pipeline,” said Hugh MacArthur, who leads Bain’s Global Private Equity Practice.
According to MacArthur, when deals do materialize, they command high prices. And with an expected hold time of about 5 years,
the margin of error for generating alpha and delivering acceptable returns to LPs has greatly narrowed. In response, GPs are
codifying their battle-tested approaches – what they are good at, what has and has not created value, and where and how their
funds have made money for investors – to build playbooks that consist of detailed, sequenced actions taken over time to maximize
value from each investment.
But could this be as good as it gets? Many GPs are apprehensive that the industry cannot sustain the torrid pace of fund-raising for
much longer. Bain expects that distributions will continue to outpace contributions and LP commitment to the PE asset class will
stay strong. However, the fund-raising environment may not be as favorable in coming years, making it important for GPs tfocus
on what makes them stand out from the pack.
Copyright 2017 © Opalesque Ltd. All Rights Reserved.
opalesque.com
8
8
Opalesque Private Equity Strategies
Issue 114 | February 28, 2017
Data Snapshot: Private Equity CTOs Add
Outsourcing, Increased Security To Priority Lists
by
Bailey McCann
Private Equity Strategies
The role of the private equity CTO has changed significantly. New technology along with a growing list of cybersecurity threats
have placed more demands on the IT department than ever before. According to a new survey of private equity CTOs from Eze
Castle Integration, these demands have led to an evolution in the role of the CTO away from simply maintaining hardware and
workflows and into making the CTO an integral part of information security and compliance support.
For 2017, respondents to the survey said that their key priorities were cybersecurity, improving customer experience and updat
-
ing older technologies. Outsourcing some business functions and technology infrastructure to cloud services providers and oth-
ers also made the list in a big way, with firms looking to outsource a variety of operations.
None of this comes as a surprise to Eze Castle’s Chief Strategy Officer, Mark Coriaty. He says that private equity CTOs have been
looking to companies like Eze Castle for those new technologies as well as guidance on how best to implement them.
“Outsourcing has grown significantly over the past three years. Firms are looking for guidance, advice and managed services
capabilities,”Coriaty tells Private Equity Strategies. “Private equity firms, specifically, are looking closely at how they manage and
maintain data securely. Many firms lack a centralized data source. We can provide a private cloud that allows for centralization and
data management.” He adds that Eze Castle also works with CTOs on a consulting basis to help them learn about best practices for
information security and maintaining compliance.
The figure below outlines what CTOs are likely to outsource over the next year:
Copyright 2017 © Opalesque Ltd. All Rights Reserved.
opalesque.com
9
9
Opalesque Private Equity Strategies
Issue 114 | February 28, 2017
In addition to outsourcing, private equity firms are also looking for ways to implement cloud services. Cloud technology
can allow firms to scale up in size rapidly, while maintaining security. Working with a cloud services provider also
eliminates the need for sprawling and complex networks of hardware.
According to Coriaty, most private equity firms are working in a private cloud environment, but some have started to
consider a partially public cloud -- also known as a hybrid cloud - when they work with counterparties to ensure consistent
security throughout processes. Over the long-term Coriaty expects that firms will continue to explore ways that they can
outsource basic business operations in order to cut costs and free up investment staff to focus on deal making.
Even as CTOs split some of their duties with third party technology providers, the role of the CTO is likely to become more
important and demanding over time. Data in the report shows that the CTO is taking on a more strategic position within
private equity firms and will be asked to contribute more heavily across in the organization. See the figure below for how
the role of the CTO is expected to evolve over the next year. More information on these trends is available in the full report
here.
Copyright 2017 © Opalesque Ltd. All Rights Reserved.
opalesque.com
10
10
Opalesque Private Equity Strategies
Issue 114 | February 28, 2017
Indigo Partners Low-Cost Airline Investments
Take Off
by Bailey McCann
Private Equity Strategies
Earlier this month, Indigo Partners, the private investment firm of Bill Franke announced that it was launching a new low cost airline in
Chile. The airline will be the first low cost provider in the region, but the model is nothing new for Franke who has made a name for himself
with critical growth investments in other low cost providers including Spirit and Frontier Airlines.
He is currently the Chairman of Frontier Airlines and Wizz Airlines another low cost provider in Eastern Europe. Prior to starting Indigo
Partners he was the CEO of America West Airlines.
JetSMART, the new Chilean airline will launch with three aircraft to take passengers throughout Chile. The airline will operate brand-new
Airbus A320 aircraft and expects to grow the fleet to nine by the end of 2018.
“We are excited to do business in Chile and believe there is an overlooked customer segment wanting to fly, but for the right price,” Franke
tells Private Equity Strategies. “There are many other reasons why Chile is an attractive entry point for the launch of a low fare carrier,
including its economic stability and aviation traffic growth; Chile’s growing economy; supportive and fair regulatory environment; and
open skies and strong bilateral treaties with neighboring countries, among others.”
Franke says that after the announcement went public he was approached by other regional entities looking to either expand JetSMART or
set up a similar low cost model in their countries.
Unlike traditional airlines, the ultra low cost model offered by JetSMART and others, gives fliers a seat on the plane and little else unless
they pay incrementally for specific services like checked baggage, legroom, beverages and other amenities. The model is popular with a
growing number of travelers who don’t mind a bare bones trip from point A to point B.
According to Franke, outreach to millennials has been positive in terms of grabbing market share for low cost carriers, because they don’t
come with the fond memories of airline glamour that defined flying in the industry’s early days. “In Europe, low-cost airlines account for
40% of all air travel. In the United States, they represent about 7% and the market share has grown for these companies by 10.3% in the
last three years. By 2034, low-fare operators are expected to account for 21% of the world market,” he says. When it comes to getting an
airline like JetSMART off the ground, Franke says finding millennials online is easiest. Outreach to older generations happens with a mix of
print ads and television. Once fliers get comfortable with the itemized approach low cost carriers use in pricing, they are usually hooked
he contends.
“This business model ensures that consumers will not pay for products and services they do not want or need. And even if you select
additional services and products, we want customers to pay less than the average fare currently available on the market”, explains Mr.
Franke. In this way, people have the option to build their experience according to their needs and the services they want.
Copyright 2017 © Opalesque Ltd. All Rights Reserved.
opalesque.com
11
11
Opalesque Private Equity Strategies
Issue 114 | February 28, 2017
Copyright 2017 © Opalesque Ltd. All Rights Reserved.
opalesque.com
12
12
Opalesque Private Equity Strategies
Issue 114 | February 28, 2017
Events
Quick Hits
Bought: Generation Growth Capital
acquired BestMark, a Minneapolis
provider of customer experience
measurement services and analytics.
Financial terms weren’t disclosed.
Fund News: LLR Equity Partners is
raising its fifth private equity fund,
according to regulatory filings. The
Philadelphia-based firm closed its last
fund on $950M in 2012.
Fund News: Kohlberg & Company has
acquired Pexco, an Alpharetta, Ga.-
based specialty plastics manufacturer,
from Odyssey Investment Partners.
Terms of the deal were not disclosed.
Bought: Dospuntos, backed by Varde
Partners, acquired Via Celere, a Spanish
development and construction com-
pany, for €90 million.
Fund News: Arle Capital Partners, a
London-based private equity firm, is
shutting down, according to Financial
News.
Fund News: Silver Lake is reportedly
moving its New York offices to the new
Hudson Yards development where it
will join other PE firms including KKR.
Fund News: WSJ reported that Terra
Firma Capital Partners has hired
Barclays and KeyBanc to find a buyer
for EverPower Wind Holdings, a wind
energy company it wishes to exit.
Fund News: Vanedge Capital Partners,
a Vancouver-based venture capital
firm, has closed its second fund with
C$161 million in capital commitments.
Best Practices for Launching &
Managing an SBIC
March 23, 2017 | New York
Hosted By: Capital Roundtable
Best Practices for Overseeing PE
Portfolio Companies
May 11, 2017 | New York
Best Practices for Investing
in Troubled Middle-Market
Companies
May 18, 2017 | New York, NY
Hosted By: Capital Roundtable
People: Edward Beckley has joined TPG
Capital to focus on global infrastruc
-
ture opportunities. He previously
led the European infrastructure fund
management unit of Macquarie.
Fund News: Aliter Capital, a new
British buyout firm focused on the
business services sector, has closed
its debut fund with £90 million in
capital commitments.
PUBLISHER
Matthias Knab
knab@opalesque.com
EDITOR
Bailey McCann
mccann@opalesque.com
ADVERTISING DIRECTOR
Greg Despoelberch
gdespo@opalesque.com
www.opalesque.com
Private Equity
strategies
Next
get_app  Login to Download this PDF
More from Matthias Knab