Thornburg Investment Management
July 01, 2016
Thornburg is a global investment firm delivering on strategy for institutions, financial professionals and investors worldwide.

Brexit Volatility Creates Opportunities

Brexit’s Ramifications

Last week's referendum in the U.K. sent risk-asset markets into a tailspin, as investors wonder what "Brexit"—the U.K.'s exit from the European Union—means for the U.K., the E.U. and, by extension, global markets. The political, economic and market implications are significant for both sides of the English Channel, and beyond. It's critical, however, to understand how the process is slated to play out near term and farther down the road and to recognize the many questions and uncertainties regarding its repercussions while keeping them in perspective. As always, the key to successful investing in an uncertain world is carefully considering future prospects relative to current prices.

  • What Happened: Although the leaders of the U.K.'s establishment Tory and Labour parties campaigned for Britain to remain in the E.U. fold, 52% of British voters elected to leave the 28-member common market, amid high voter turnout of 72%. Tory Prime Minister David Cameron, who is credited with pushing economic reforms that helped make the U.K. Europe's most dynamic large economy, has resigned in the wake of the vote. Opposition Labour Party leader Jeremy Corbyn, meanwhile, has lost a no confidence vote by a wide margin after a slew of resignations from his shadow administration. New leaders of both parties will be selected.
  • What's the Political Worry: Concerns of political contagion have grown dramatically, as calls for similar referenda among other E.U. members, and most importantly from those that use the common euro currency, spread in the wake of the vote. It's important to note, however, that the nationalist, populist parties pushing for similar "exit" votes aren't in power where their voices are loudest: France, Italy and the Netherlands. That said, there is a risk that Scotland, which in last week's Brexit balloting, voted to stay in the E.U., could hold another referendum on its continued presence in the U.K., after electing to remain a part of Great Britain two years ago. Northern Ireland also voted to stay in the E.U., and would no doubt like to keep its borders open with its cousins to the South, E.U.-member Ireland.
  • What's the Economic Concern: Economists generally expect the U.K. to fall into a near-term recession, as investment projects get put on hold; housing, commercial & industrial real estate cools amid expectations of lower prices and fears grow that London's crucial financial services economy may not have as much access in a future outside the E.U. as it currently enjoys. As for continental Europe, it's losing the world's fifth-biggest economy and the fastest-growing of Europe's large economies, not to mention its biggest military.

The degree to which Brexit and the associated economic and political risks in the U.K. and continental Europe affect the day-to-day operations of a company or a sovereign issuer must be evaluated against its current business or economic fundamentals and future prospects. The volatility in asset prices, after all, may well not reflect meaningful changes in those fundamentals. For long-term investors, such price dislocations can present excellent entry points to world-class, overseas companies or sovereign debt that, however the Brexit process plays out, continue to have excellent prospects.

Important Information

The views expressed are those of Thornburg Investment Management. These views are subject to change at any time in response to changing circumstances in the markets and are not intended to predict or guarantee the future performance of any individual security or the markets generally, nor are they intended to predict the future performance of any Thornburg Investment Management account, strategy or fund.

Additional risks may be associated with investments outside the United States, especially in emerging markets, including currency fluctuations, illiquidity, volatility, and political and economic risks.

Before investing, carefully consider the Fund's investment goals, risks, charges, and expenses. For a prospectus or summary prospectus containing this and other information, contact your financial advisor or visit our thornburg.com . Read them carefully before investing.

Thornburg Investment Management®
Thornburg Securities Corporation®, Distributor
2300 North Ridgetop Road
Santa Fe, NM 87506
877-215-1330
advisor@thornburg.com

© 2016 Thornburg Investment Management, Inc. All rights reserved.

Thornburg Investment Management, Inc. mutual funds are sold through investment professionals including investment advisors, brokerage firms, bank trust departments, trust companies and certain other financial intermediaries. Thornburg Investment Management, Inc. does not offer personalized investment advice. Thornburg Securities Corporation (TSC) does not act as broker of record for investors.

Not FDIC Insured, May Lose Value, No Bank Guarantee.


 




 


JUNE 2016
Beyond the economic loss of the U.K.,
which also boasts Europe’s most robust
armed forces, the potential political impli
-
cations are significant. The fear is Brexit
will encourage more exit votes in other
E.U. member states, particularly among
the 19 members who joined the eurozone,
in which monetary union was created
without fiscal union. That created funda
-
mental contradictions in economic policy
that have festered since the euro’s 1999
deadline for the first round of adoption
by participating states. Britain, of course,
doesn’t participate in the eurozone or the
26-member Schengen Area accord, which
allows for the passport-free movement of
people between states. But given its access
to the E.U. common market, it was obli
-
gated to allow citizens of other E.U. states
to work and reside in the U.K.
Economic Contradictions
As with “Grexit” a few years ago, the
monetary and fiscal contradictions have
weighed heavily on various members.
The biggest, though, wasn’t Greece,
which adopted the euro in 2001. It was
Italy, where the anti-establishment,
euro-sceptic 5-Star Movement swept lo
-
cal elections just over a week ago. As the
lira was replaced by the euro at too high
a rate, it badly undercut the competi
-
tiveness of Italy’s storied manufacturing
sector, hurting its employment, income,
and broad economic growth ever since,
and leaving its total debt load an increas
-
ingly onerous burden to bear. Technically,
there’s no euro exit mechanism. But were
a eurozone member’s electorate to vote for
an exit, it might ultimately precipitate the
euro’s demise. In the wake of the Brexit
vote, populist, nationalist parties have
called for similar votes in France and the
Netherlands.
We would note, however, that no such
anti-E.U. or eurozone-sceptic party has
ascended to national power in a mem
-
ber state, and, depending on how things
evolve for the U.K., none may. Spain’s
ruling market-friendly Partido Popular
gained legislative seats in general elections
Sunday, while the center-left, establish
-
ment PSOE also came out better than ex
-
pected against the leftist Podemos party.
Nonetheless, the euro’s deflationary im
-
pact on several eurozone countries (mainly
in the southern periphery) continues to
animate anti-establishment sentiment
among electorates, particularly among
lesser-educated, native-born segments
that, fairly or unfairly, blame the E.U. and
Brexit Roils Markets, Creating Risks and
Opportunities
Charles Roth |
Global Markets Editor
thornburg.com | 8 7 7. 2 15 .13 3 0
The British voted in a June 23 referendum to leave the 28-member European Union, the biggest common market in the
world. Markets have been volatile, rising in the prelude to the “Brexit” vote on expectations that the “remain” campaign
would win and then going into a tailspin as the “leave” camp definitively won with 52% of a vote in which a high 72% of
the electorate participated. Risk markets fell sharply and safe-haven sovereign yields dropped to multi-year or record lows as
questions about the economic and political repercussions of the vote gripped investors. The United Kingdom is the world’s
fifth-largest economy and the second-biggest in Europe after Germany. It’s also Europe’s fastest growing major economy,
averaging 2.1% annual growth over the last five years, easily outpacing Germany’s 1.6% growth in the period as well as the
eurozone’s anemic 0.14% rate.
2
the “dirigiste” bureaucrats in Brussels for
years of, in many cases, marginal employ
-
ment and wage growth.
Immigration and Desired Limits
on Freedom of Movement
The other factor driving growing seg
-
ments of national electorates in Europe
is immigration across the E.U. and espe
-
cially the refugee crisis, which is putting
the Schengen Area accord increasingly at
risk. Nigel Farage, the leader of the far-
right U.K. Independence Party and one of
the most vocal Brexit proponents, made
limiting immigration one of his top cam
-
paign points. While migrants from the
Middle East might help offset the chal
-
lenges facing Europe’s aging demograph
-
ics, they generally haven’t been easily
assimilated, and terrorist attacks, most re
-
cently in Paris and Brussels, clearly don’t
help. Coupled with the lack of economic
growth, the populist, nationalist par
-
ties have been gaining electoral ground
across Europe. Barring a shift in current
economic, social, and political trends, the
euro’s longer-term viability may well be
at risk. That’s the underlying fear driving
market volatility.
Why Brexit?
As a member of the E.U. customs union,
Britain has been subject to myriad regu
-
lations promulgated by unelected com
-
missions in Brussels, while E.U. courts
can overrule the British Parliament. Over
the decades, the E.U. “harmonization”
push has given rise to massive bureaucracy
that, those who favor “Brexit” argued,
runs roughshod over local political, eco
-
nomic, and social decision-making. That
can involve highly impactful issues such
as taxation and labor regulation, as well
as silly ones, such as the spelling of words
or the required shape of fruits and vege
-
tables. E.U. defenders contend that some
national sovereignty must be sacrificed
for the greater good derived from the free
movement of goods, services, and people.
They add that Britain does have more lee
-
way to influence domestic policies than is
generally thought and point to Germany’s
welfare and labor market reforms in 2003
and 2004, and Spain’s more recently un
-
der the Partido Popular.
Nonetheless, Brexit supporters argued
there’s not enough leeway, and charge
that the supranational E.U. has stifled
innovation and economic growth. They
point to the E.U.’s poor economic record
in recent times. In today’s digital world,
why has nothing on the order of Apple,
Amazon, Facebook, Google, Netflix, etc.,
been born in Europe? Brexit advocates
also note that while the E.U. has allowed
for free trade within the block, it’s been
quite protectionist in promoting free
trade agreements (FTA) with countries
and customs unions outside Europe, and
doesn’t allow the U.K., which has a long
history of foreign trade, to unilaterally ne
-
gotiate its own FTAs. Instead, the E.U.’s
FTAs often involve small countries—such
as Chile, Colombia, and Singapore—that
don’t really impact member states’ pro
-
ducers and often exclude services, which
comprise the bulk of the U.K.’s economy.
Next Steps
Initially, nothing happens on the legisla
-
tive front. Given that Tory Prime Minis
-
ter David Cameron argued vigorously for
the U.K. to remain in the E.U., he has re
-
signed. Meanwhile, Labour leader Jeremy
Corbyn has lost a no-confidence vote by a
wide margin after a slew of resignations
from his shadow administration. New
leaders of both parties will be selected.
Cameron has insisted the next conserva
-
tive party leader, who will be appointed in
October, should be the one to invoke Ar
-
ticle 50 of the Lisbon Treaty, which will
formally start the separation process. E.U.
officials, on the other hand, are pushing
to have the process, which once initiated
will run on a two-year clock, start im
-
mediately to avoid “a prolonged period of
uncertainty,” as E.U. Commission Pres
-
ident Jean-Claude Junker said Tuesday,
while German Chancellor Angela Merkel
warned that the U.K. won’t be allowed
to “cherry pick” the most advantageous
elements of E.U. membership during the
negotiations.
Once the clock starts ticking, the U.K.
will seek to cut its current E.U. ties and
reestablish trade, investment, and immi
-
gration links with the E.U. on its own
terms, perhaps similar to those enjoyed
by Norway. The E.U., on the other hand,
is expected to punish the U.K. in setting
harsher terms for those links to dissuade
other members of the E.U., and especially
the eurozone, from leaving. Markets fear
that the U.K. won’t fare as well outside the
E.U. as it has inside. It should be noted
that trade accords can take many years to
hammer out, given their complexity. The
E.U.–Canada trade agreement has taken
seven years to reach, yet it doesn’t include
fully liberalized trade in financial services
and still hasn’t been ratified. That’s a big
drawback for the U.K., as services com
-
prise four-fifths of its economy, and its ra
-
tio of financial services exports to GDP is
the highest in the Group of Seven indus
-
trialized nations at about one-third.
But as Britain renegotiates its economic
ties with the E.U. over the next couple
years, businesses are unlikely to invest,
and there may even be an exodus of expats
who currently live in the U.K. under E.U.
“passporting rights” (an estimated three
million people). It’s also reasonable to as
-
sume foreign direct investment may de
-
cline as global businesses no longer view
the U.K. as the ideal place to set up shop.
Markets Fall Out, Then Find Their
Footing
These expectations caused U.K. risk as
-
set prices to swoon in the two trading
sessions subsequent to the vote, with the
pound weakening to a 31-year low before
stabilizing Tuesday, while U.K. stocks
also took a beating before finding their
footing, and the 10-year U.K. government
bond yield dropped below 1% for the first
time ever. Continental European stocks
and the euro also came under significant
selling pressure, and in some equity mar
-
kets even more than in the U.K., before
recovering somewhat Tuesday.
Markets will likely continue to experience
tremendous volatility as the U.K. seeks
to define its future relationship with the
E.U., and the E.U. tries to keep its re
-
maining members, especially in the euro
-
zone, on board. Investors should keep in
3
mind that, while the U.K. faces an uphill
climb near-term, as time passes, cooler
heads at both sides of the negotiating
table may prevail, hammering out trade,
investment, and labor migration terms
acceptable to all. Indeed, there’s a chance
that under articles 46 and 47 of the pend
-
ing “Markets in Financial Instruments
Regulation,” many rights now extended
to E.U. passport holders can be extended
to non-E.U. countries and their financial
services providers. The U.K. may be able
to advance similar accords with the U.S.,
and Commonwealth countries, such as
Canada and Australia, at a quicker clip
than has customarily been the case.
Meanwhile, the Brexit vote may prompt
the European Commission to reevaluate
its own “harmonization” efforts, perhaps
facilitating greater federalism within the
common market. To keep their populist,
nationalist parties on the fringe and not in
power, more member state governments
may also decide to undertake the pro-
growth structural reforms that Germany
and Spain have already undertaken.
Our Take
We believe the way to manage “event
risks” such as Brexit is to stay rational
and look for opportunities as they arise,
around the globe. Investors should re
-
member that nearly 50% of global market
capitalization is outside the U.S., based on
country weights of the MSCI All-Coun
-
try World Index, with Europe and the
U.K. together representing almost a quar
-
ter of that. Moreover, European Union
GDP rivals in size that of the U.S.
Many of our portfolios were positioned
with higher-than-normal cash positions
ahead of the vote, and have taken ad
-
vantage of the volatility to add to current
positions or initiate new ones from their
wish lists, many of which included com
-
panies that they previously held but had
become too richly valued.
Our fundamental research at the indi
-
vidual and portfolio levels gives us deep
knowledge of each of our positions, their
operating contexts and end markets. This
is invaluable during times of significant
price dislocations, when relative value
bargains can be obtained. For long-term
investors, short-term volatility affecting
asset prices of companies and countries
with sound fundamentals and promising
prospects can ultimately prove very prof
-
itable.
n
For more articles and information about our
active approach visit www.thornburg.com.
We believe the way to manage “event risks” such as
Brexit is to stay rational and look for opportunities
as they arise, around the globe. Investors should
remember that nearly 50% of global market
capitalization is outside the U.S.
The views expressed by Mr. Roth reflect his professional opinions and are subject to change. Under no circumstances does the information contained within represent a recom
-
mendation to buy or sell any security.
Investments carry risks, including possible loss of principal. Additional risks may be associated with investments outside the United States, especially in emerging markets,
including currency fluctuations, illiquidity, volatility, and political and economic risks. Investments in small- and mid-capitalization companies may increase the risk of greater
price fluctuations. Investments in the Fund are not FDIC insured, nor are they bank deposits or guaranteed by a bank or any other entity.
The MSCI All Country (AC) World Index is a market capitalization weighted index that is representative of the market structure of 46 developed and emerging market countries in
North and South America, Europe, Africa, and the Pacific Rim. The index is calculated with net dividends reinvested in U.S. dollars.
Gross Domestic Product (GDP) – A country’s income minus foreign investments: the total value of all goods and services produced within a country in a year, minus net income
from investments in other countries.
Sovereign debt – Government debt that has been issued in a foreign currency.
Thornburg mutual funds are distributed by Thornburg Securities Corporation.
Past performance does not guarantee future results.
Before investing, carefully consider the Fund’s investment goals, risks, charges, and expenses. For a prospectus or summary
prospectus containing this and other information, contact your financial advisor or visit thornburg.com. Read them carefully
before investing.
6/29/16
© 2016 Thornburg Investment Management, Inc. | 2300 North Ridgetop Road | Santa Fe, New Mexico 87506 | 877.215.1330
TH3681
Next
get_app  Login to Download this PDF
Disclaimers & Disclosureskeyboard_arrow_up

To learn more, please visit www.thornburg.com

The views expressed by the portfolio managers reflect their professional opinions and are subject to change. Under no circumstances does the information contained within represent a recommendation to buy or sell any security. Investments carry risks, including possible loss of principal. Investments carry risks, including possible loss of principal. Portfolios investing in bonds have the same interest rate, inflation, and credit risks that are associated with the underlying bonds. The value of bonds will fluctuate relative to changes in interest rates, decreasing when interest rates rise. Unlike bonds, bond funds have ongoing fees and expenses. Investments in the Funds are not FDIC insured, nor are they bank deposits or guaranteed by a bank or any other entity. Please see our glossary for a definition of terms: http://www.thornburg.com/legal/glossary.aspx Thornburg mutual funds are distributed by Thornburg Securities Corporation. Thornburg Investment Management, Inc. mutual funds are sold through investment professionals including investment advisors, brokerage firms, bank trust departments, trust companies and certain other financial intermediaries. Thornburg Securities Corporation (TSC) does not act as broker of record for investors.

Before investing, carefully consider the Fund’s investment goals, risks, charges, and expenses. For a prospectus or summary prospectus containing this and other information, contact your financial advisor or visit our literature center. Read them carefully before investing: https://www.thornburg.com/forms-literature/product-literature/mutual-funds/index.aspx



More from Thornburg Investment Management